What's the world's best supplement?
Protein vs Creatine

What is protein and which one is the best?

Protein powders can come in several different forms: The three main proteins used for bodybuilding include:

  • Whey – The most effective protein for building muscle. Dramatically increases the speed of protein synthesis (re-building).
  • Casein – Slow digesting protein from cow’s milk. Has little effect on protein synthesis, though is very effective at decreasing protein breakdown.
  • Soy – Manufactured from soya beans, has a high nutritional value though is commonly seen as a lower quality of protein.

What is creatine and where is it found?

Unlike most supplements that athletes use, creatine is neither a vitamin, mineral, herb nor hormone.

It is a naturally occurring amino acid that is found in our body that has the chemical name methyl guanidine-acetic acid.

As most of you are already aware, amino acids are the building blocks of proteins. The majority of creatine (about 95%) is located in the skeletal muscle system, and the remaining 5% is in the brain, heart and testes.

We acquire most of the creatine in our system by consuming meats and fish as well as dairy products, egg whites, nuts and seeds.

Although the human body has a way of storing very high amounts of creatine to enhance recovery and muscle power, it is quite challenging to consume enough food to provide the same amount of creatine that using supplements will. In fact most of the creatine found naturally is foods is disposed of during cooking! 

Where does whey protein come from?

Whey protein comes from cow’s milk. The milk itself is 87% water and 13% milk solids. From those solids the proteins are removed in which only 20% of it is whey protein.

From that highly filtered protein, whey protein isolate is formed and is the highest quality, lowest fat protein form on the market with +90% protein per serving.

What is the purpose of creatine?

Now that you know what creatine is and how your body manufactures it, let’s study the purpose it serves…especially to athletes.

Process...

Creatine’s main benefit is its ability to aid in the production of energy. When ATP (adenosine triphosphate) loses one of its phosphate molecules and becomes ADP (adenosine diphosphate), it must be converted back to ATP in order for the molecule to be able to produce energy again.

The creatine in our body is mostly stored as creatine phosphate (known as phosphocreatine), and it will donate its phosphate to the ADP which renews the ATP molecule and it can now produce energy.

Why is whey protein so popular?

Apart from its great value for money, whey protein is the most complete, fastest digesting, has a high biological value and contains branched chain amino acids.

How does whey protein impact on muscle growth?

Although many athletes see protein as an every day supplement, little understand the true effect is has on the body.

Why protein’s primary function is aiding in protein synthesis. This is process your muscle fibres go through to regenerate after a workout. This essential process determines whether the muscle tissue will be re-built into a larger and stronger form.

How does creatine stimulate muscle growth?

Although creatine’s role in the energy production process is its most notable trait, there is evidence that creatine can stimulate muscle growth.

It does this in a couple of different ways. By allowing you to perform more work as a result of additional energy, increased protein synthesis is stimulated.

Secondly, when an abundance of creatine phosphate is stored in the muscle, the muscle will hold more water in its cells and become what is known as “volumized” or “super-hydrated.”

The more volumized a muscle is, it will promote the synthesis of protein as well as deter the breakdown of protein.

Volumizing the muscle will also create an environment where an increased level of Glycogen synthesis will take place.

Increased protein synthesis along with training will lead to muscle growth.

There is also scientific evidence that shows supplementation with creatine causes muscle tears to repair themselves quicker.

How much protein should I be taking then?

It’s a common myth that you can only digest 30grams of protein at one time.

How much protein that can be digested is not the important factor, it’s how much can be utilzised that has a massive impact on muscle growth.

Your goal when using protein supplements is to keep the process of protein synthesis pumping along steadily.

Now if your goal is to add weight to your frame there needs to be a certain amount of consistent input. Work of the measure of 1.5grams of protein per pound of body weight.

This means that a 200 lbs (90kg) bodybuilder should be consuming around 250-300 grams of protein per day from food sources of lean meats, eggs vegetables and of course whey protein isolate powders.

The Bottom Line...

To sum all of this up, I believe that whey protein is the greatest supplement of all. It is absolutely essential for protein synthesis and without this process there is no muscular development.

On the other hand, creatine is an awesome supplement on its own. You should treat creatine as purely a performance based supplement as it has a dramatic influence on energy creation which allows you as an athlete to train harder and longer, equalling more protein synthesis, so therefore more growth! As a side note, creatine should be taken in cycles of around 8-12 weeks, then off for 4 weeks and repeat. 


Tired of little or no results?

Join the thousands of people who have discovered how my Permanent Muscle program gives you every tool required including; workouts, meal plans, exercises and more to achieve stunning muscle building results over the next 6 months.

 

Even more of my methods for how to build muscle fast!

 

Comments
Add New Search
dxliu  - protein drinks gave me acnes   |2010-02-20 19:33:08
i was using some kind of protein drinks and they gave me so many acnes on my face. about 3 months ago i stopped taking them and all the acnes went away.is that true protein drinks give you acnes?
Tom Tychansky  - My Creatine & Protein Stack...   |2009-11-28 17:13:27
When it comes to protein I'm 50/50 with how stingy I am...

Post work-out I use Allmax Nutrition Isoflex (120cal, 30g protein, 1g carb from sugar, 0g fat)[with waxy maize for complex carbs & some extra glutamine] mixed with water.

Morning & before bed shakes are mixed with 250mL of Skim Milk. I mix in some Glutamine & a scoop of a whey blend, this is where I'm not too picky, whatever's on sale(Syntha 6, Nitro-Tech, ON Gold Standard, MyoFusion, etc) I like to mix with milk because the casein helps slow down the protein delivery making it even more of a sustained release, plus most whey blends are only about 20g of protein & the milk adds another 9-10!

For Creatine I'm using Fusion Bodybuilding Purple K. From what I've learned this is the way to go if you're not going for size as it's a "Kre-Alkalyn" which doesn't promote water retension & is suppose to deliver right to the skelital muscles. Because of that it doesn't need to be cycled as it has little effect on your liver like most monohydrates. 1 pill - 1.5g creatine, I follow the recommended dose on the bottle 1-2 pre & post. For Wrestling days I take 1 pre, 2 post, resistance training days are 2 & 2.
Jay  - creatine   |2009-10-13 16:44:19
i heard you have to be of a certian age before taking creatine is that true?

personaly i have never seen a creatine product or supplement so i dont know.



Jay
Alex  - Hemp Protein   |2009-08-02 23:42:59
what does everyone think of hemp protein? im lactose intolerant so i dont fuck with whey and i've heard bad stuff about soy health wise
Reuben Bajada  - re: Creatine Cycles ?   |2009-07-08 18:13:55
Danilo wrote:
Is realy necessary to do creatine cycles ?


Hi Danilo,

The most important part of a creatine cycle is the loading phase at the start, where you need to intake around 4 times your standard daily serving for the first 5 days.

This saturates your creatine stores inside your muscle, ensuring you have a sufficient supply for your workouts.

From then on, take your standard daily serving which is the 'maintenance phase'

Reduce the supplementation of creatine to just a few grams (0.03grams/kilogram body weight) (0.0136 grams / pound of bodyweight) a day for a maximum of 8 weeks.

The reason for the maintenance phase is to replace the amount of creatine degraded on a daily basis. In case you haven’t guessed the maintenance amount of creatine is roughly equal to how much creatine your body uses daily.

Regards
Reuben
Danilo  - Creatine Cycles ?   |2009-07-08 13:47:51
Is realy necessary to do creatine cycles ?
Hardeep Singh {HARDY}  - supplements   |2009-06-06 07:18:00
I use Protein powder With milk and Bananas & I eat boiled potatos before going to GYM to gain muscle......:P
Logan   |2009-06-05 13:05:31
I use the "promax extreme" stuff from maximuscle - i think it has protein and creatine in it. Use it before and after work out and only started using it since i got a personal trainer (Since Feb 09). I havent tried any other brands so would welcome suggestions if anyone knows of anything better. I guess i've seen results but reckon its probably down to the fact im training harder now. can't hurt to take the supplements eh? I haven't noticed any side effects really.
bas3ballking305@aim.com  - hydration   |2009-06-04 13:15:27
the thing with creatine too is that you most def need to drink more water. it sgood to dring about a gallon a day, then on creatine, almost double. my friends in baseball in practice have had some freak accidents and reoccuring muscle pulls
Shannon, Melbourne  - Protein and Creatine   |2009-06-02 18:21:34
I use a whey protein at the moment with a creatine, also take bcaa's as well. I find that the most i get out of my training doesn't come from my supplements, but from my diet and rest. If i eat enough, and get enough sleep, all the supplements do for me are aide in recovery i beleive.
v  - protein v creatine   |2009-06-02 12:45:50
I take a protein isolate before and after a workout and 5grams of craetine,works for me.
adam neth  - supplements   |2009-06-02 10:31:38
i've used wheybolic extreme 60 and i got the best results possible. along with plain creatine monohydrate. works amazingly. cycle on and off of that. i also have black powder mri, and also bsn's n.o. explode. these work well when you cycle them. get l-arginine and you'll be set with huge pumps, and growing massively. crossfit.com, throw in some of their workouts along with your original and you're going to see improvments. great ones.
Alex  - supplements   |2009-06-01 21:06:30
The only supplement I have taken is whey protein. I have not been taking it very long, so I have not yet noticed a large differences. I have been able to build more lean muscle though, but I attribute it mailny to working out more. The two main brands I use are Muscle Milk, and EAS. So far I have not experienced any side effects.
eliot  - don't believe the hype   |2009-06-01 21:02:55
I've tried many different whey proteins, pre workout drinks, creatines, no2 products, etc. Not a fan of NanoVapor. I used GNC's leucine stack for a long time before it was discontinued. It worked well. I cycle on and off of no explode and add creatine monohydrate to it (because it only has 1 gram per serving). All this hype about cutting edge creatines is hype. I have found that monohydrate works as well or better. Hated MRI products, tried both creatine and NO2 by them. I like BSN in general, their Syntha 6 protein tastes great with just water, and is low in fat and sugar. The most important supplements to me are: whey protein, creatine monohydrate, leucine, glutamine, citrulline and arginine (these you should cycle on and off if you decide to use at all), and caffeine in some form if you like that extra kick. All these overpriced overhyped "new" formulas for protein and preworkout/postworkout are mostly just hype. Stick with the basics.
keith  - weight gaining suplements.   |2009-06-01 16:28:47
i started to build my body 8 months ago.
so i am going trhrough A LOT of misguided information and trial and error phases.i tried six star whey protein and really i noticed next to no result.i tried superpump 250 nitric oxide next and discoverd it definetly gave me a liitle extra focus in the gym and a bit more strenght in the gym but im still not getting the desired results.so after lots of study im now trying muscle juice 2544 for a weight gainer and ON gold whey ,for post workouts.i only have it two days so if this lot fails i really dont know what to do.
Chris  - whey protein isolate!   |2009-06-01 08:13:06
I dabbled with a bunch of supps: nitric oxide, creatine, bunch of wheys, waxy maise, aminos, fat burners. Out of all of them def whey protein isolate. I only use about 80-100 grams of it a day, in addition to 150-200 grams of meat/egg proteins. I i especially use it around the time of and after my workouts since it is so quickly digested, unlike milk, cheese, and meat.
I tried cell tech for creatine and i did it for 2 months. It made me wicked bloated cuz it has like 50 grams of sugat. It made my 6 pack go away, it game me achne, and when i cyled of of it i feel like i just pissed out my results. I dunno if i did something wrong but it didnt really work for me.
NO products are cool cuz they give u a crazy pump and i hear that is good cuz when u have ur shakes and whatever the nutrients are rushed to ur mucles since the veins and vessels are so much more enlarged. I dont really use them tho. i found if i used themtoo much when i stopped, i was much weaker.
fat burners like green tea extract and caffine before workouts is awesome, but i never tried that hydroxicut or any of the more hardcore stuff.
waxy maise is a fast digesting carb and i liked that its for recovery after workouts. i still use that soemtimes i supplement for other fast digesting carbs. anyways i agree with reuben whey isolate = greatness

the Bostonian,
Chris
Alex Cj  - supplements   |2009-06-01 07:22:22
I just started work out for last 7 month.I'm using Dymatize Mega Gainer for pre-workout and post workout.I do feel sleepy and no strength after workout.Just recently I added Muscle Tech Anator into my supplement for post-workout.I don't feel sleepy and no strength,which mean I can workout before my job start.Previously, I only can workout during 2day off a week.
Glenn  - No need   |2009-06-01 01:42:01
This year I trained without supplements.
I had to drink a shitload of milk and eat a lot of different types of food (chicken, cottage cheese,...) to get enough protein in my body though.
I find that you don't really need whey, but it's an easy way of getting protein and it saves a LOT of time that otherwise would be lost by eating. I'm gonna start again on whey though ;)

Best of luck to all you brutal muscle beasts
Greetz from Belgium
Jamie  - Supplements   |2009-06-01 00:31:54
I've only just started using supplements, i've finished my first tub of protein whey (iso2nutrition)Now i've got a creatine/protein mix Cant say its given me any boost during training but i have noticed that i dont ache as much the day after a session,i guess that means i can train harder, I have got a alot healthier eating wise but incorporated with the supplements seem to have abit more energy
Hassan   |2009-05-31 23:44:25
I m using whey protein in addition to Nitric oxide , allmax muscle prime is excellent super pumped ,i m not sure if it is only me or the pre workout supplement ;)
Raymond  - nitric oxide   |2009-05-31 22:15:50
I have been using Nitric Oxide as a pre-workout supplement. It seems to help intensify my workouts and help me push harder. It does have a downside, that is you can actually overdose on it so you HAVE TO FOLLOW THE INSTRUCTIONS! Also some brands I did not like the feeling it gave me. Most notably was NaNoVapor. It made my head feel a bit swimmy and made me tired when it wore off.
Syme  - supplements   |2009-05-31 22:08:09
I used weightgainers in combination with a lot of training and food to get to my desired weight. Since then I've been taking creatine and Whey protein for my training, which seems to be the right choice.

However, I've also used some of the "hyped" supplements,, but after doing a little research on my own, I figured 'back to basics' (using just creatine and whey) was the best thing to do. It saved me a lot of money. Wish I would've been able to read this article ealier,, then I wouldn't have bought those supplements in the first place!

Greetings from Holland, Alkmaar
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."

 
Never Ending Dedication Towards Proven Training Excellence.                                                     
© 2010 | BuildingMuscleWorldwide.com | Sitemap | Disclaimer